How to Choose the Right Employer of Record (EOR) Provider

Why EOR Selection is a Legal Decision (Not Just an HR One)

An EOR sits between your company and the employee as the local legal employer. Done well, this model helps you hire quickly while staying aligned with local labor, tax, and benefits requirements. Done poorly, the EOR becomes a single point of failure: misclassification exposure, payroll errors, unlawful terminations, data transfer risk, and inconsistent employee experience across markets.

And the compliance bar is rising. For example, EU employers are preparing for the Pay Transparency Directive (EU) 2023/970, which Member States must transpose by 7 June 2026, with real implications for recruitment practices, pay structures, and reporting readiness.

‍

12 Factors to Consider When Selecting an Employer of Record

When you choose an Employer of Record (EOR), you’re not just buying “payroll abroad.” You’re appointing a legal employer in-country, so the EOR’s compliance posture becomes your risk profile. Here’s what I would look for if I wanted to scaling fast.

1. The EOR’s Employment Model: Owned Entities vs Partner Reliance

The first question I ask is simple: who actually employs the worker?

EORs typically operate through:

• Wholly-owned local entities (the provider is the employer via its own company in that country), or
• Partner networks (a third-party local employer handles employment, payroll, and HR admin), or
• A hybrid of both.

Partner models aren’t automatically wrong, but they can increase complexity: more subprocessors, more variation in HR execution, and more “hand-offs” when things get urgent (e.g., payroll errors, audits, terminations). If I’m optimizing for consistency, speed, and governance, I generally prefer strong coverage via owned entities, especially in my priority markets.

What I ask for:

• The legal name of the employing entity per country
• Whether any third parties are involved (and where)
• Who signs the employment agreement and who carries day-to-day HR obligations

2. Pricing That’s Transparent Enough to Forecast Globally

It’s important for me to find an EOR with transparent pricing. Some providers may have hidden fees, like onboarding and offboarding charges, which can increase costs unexpectedly. I look for an EOR that clearly communicates all potential expenses upfront, is straightforward in their invoicing, cost effective, and offers a clear breakdown of what’s included in their pricing.

Common surprises include:

• onboarding/offboarding fees
• “dedicated support” fees
• benefit administration add-ons
• FX markups hidden in exchange rates
• fees triggered by contract amendments or country changes

What good looks like: a single invoice model I can reconcile, a breakdown of pass-through costs vs service fees, and flexibility that fits scaling teams (monthly pricing rather than forcing annual commitments).

3. What Level Of Support Can You Expect From The EOR?

The level of support an EOR provides can make or break your global employment strategy. Quick response times and hands-on support are essential, especially when dealing with complex issues like payroll queries or legal compliance in jurisdictions you might be unfamiliar with.

Before bringing an EOR provider on board, check their public reviews on platforms like G2 and Trustpilot. Additionally, ensure that the EOR offers dedicated support for your employees to ensure employee satisfaction and retention. Be sure to ask if dedicated support comes free of charge, as some EOR providers charge extra for this service.

4. How Extensive Is The EOR Country Coverage?

Coverage matters in two ways:

1. Where they can hire today, and
2. Where they can support you next, without forcing a provider change mid-scale.

Your EOR provider should have a strong presence in the countries where you wish to expand in the short-term and in the long run. In cases where they do not operate in your desired country, your growth might be hampered if you're locked into a contract you’re unhappy with. Some providers also charge fixed offboarding fees – it’s a good idea to ask whether this is the case before you commit to a provider.

Identify a company with comprehensive country coverage. For example, Playroll operates in over 180+ regions and offers the extensive coverage required to support your global ambitions. 

5. Ability to Support Both Employees and Contractors (with Classification Help)

An ideal EOR should help you hire both full-time employees and contractors legally. This flexibility is essential as your workforce needs may evolve over time. It’s much easier to use one service provider that can cater for all potential needs, than having to choose different providers to hire full-time employees and contractors.

Additionally, the EOR provider should be able to assist with classifying your workers correctly to avoid the penalties associated with misclassifying employees as contractors, and convert contractors to full-time employees if needed. 

A strong EOR should support:

• compliant employee hiring
• contractor engagement (where offered)
• classification guidance to reduce misclassification risk
• pathways to convert contractors into employees cleanly

6. Do They Offer a Robust Portfolio of Local and Global Benefits?

Competitive employee benefits are a key component of attracting and retaining top talent. Your EOR should offer a comprehensive benefits package that includes both local benefits and global options. 

Enquire about additional services like benefits management and visa support. The more robust and flexible the benefits, the better equipped you’ll be to support your international team no matter any curveballs that might come your way.

7. How Will Payroll Work for Your Remote Employees?

Timely and accurate payroll is a non-negotiable part of your day-to-day operations when managing a global workforce. Having delayed and faulty payroll can result in great reputational harm to your business and potential legal fallout. Ensure the EOR has a proven track record of paying employees on time and offers a user-friendly payroll system.

Before committing, ask for a demonstration of how their payroll system works and whether it provides a clear view of all transactions in one place. Ask how their invoicing system works, as some providers can make this needlessly complex.

8. How Do They Keep Your Data Safe?

An EOR processes highly sensitive data: passports, addresses, bank details, compensation, and sometimes family/health information.

You should assess:

• GDPR alignment and security posture
• data processing agreements and retention schedules
• subprocessor lists (especially in partner models)
• cross-border transfer safeguards

This matters even more as HR teams increasingly use automated screening and HR analytics. In the EU, the AI Act (Regulation (EU) 2024/1689) is now law, with a phased rollout and significant compliance implications for certain AI uses, including employment-related contexts.

9. Approaches to Mitigating Compliance Risks

Compliance with local labor laws is one of the main reasons to partner with an EOR. The right EOR should have a team of experts on hand to help you navigate challenges such as employee misclassification risk, and meeting all compliance requirements in new markets. Again, be sure to check if the EOR provider has a track record of quick response times, as you might need fast support when it comes to questions of compliance.

Ask about their legal expertise in the specific countries you’re interested in and how they help you stay compliant with local regulations.  

10. How Flexible Are They When It Comes to Employment Contracts?

Employment contracts can vary across different regions and your EOR should be flexible to your specific needs and can create customized agreements if needed. Ask about their process for amending contracts and how long it typically takes. 

Flexibility in this area ensures your contracts are aligned with both local laws and your business objectives. 

11. How Will the EOR Help with Employment Terminations?

Employee terminations can be difficult and complicated, making it a matter that should be handled carefully. Ensure the EOR has a clear and compliant process for managing terminations, including support for both the employer and the employee during the offboarding process. Understand this process thoroughly before entering into a partnership to prevent legal issues in the future.

12. Do They Support the Transfer Between EOR Entities and Client-Owned Entities?

If you're considering moving an employee from an EOR to one of your own entities, many EOR providers require a ‘resign and rehire’ process. During this process,  the employee resigns from the EOR and is rehired by your entity. This approach can complicate the businesses’ relationship with the employee.

Clarify with the EOR if they offer a flexible transfer process.

‍

Checklist for Selecting a Employer of Record

‍

Final Thoughts: Choose an EOR You Can Grow With

The right EOR gives you more than market access. It gives you repeatable compliance, the kind you can defend with documentation when you scale headcount, get audited, raise funding, or enter more regulated markets.

And because the regulatory environment is actively evolving (pay transparency rules (EU), AI governance (EU), workforce fairness standards (UK), and broader due diligence expectations in value chains (EU)) Playroll always advise choosing a provider that can show how they operationalize change, not just that they “monitor laws.”

Compare EOR providers and book a demo with Playroll today to explore how we can support your international growth.