Playroll Blog
Company Updates
Contractor Management
Employer Of Record
Global HR
Global Payroll
Legal And Compliance
Regulatory Updates

How to Choose the Right Payroll Service for Your Business

Having trouble finding a global payroll solution that is the right fit for your business ? Here's your easy guide to choose a payroll provider that will support your business growth.

Global Payroll

Milani Notshe

June 18, 2025

8 mins

Copied to Clipboard

Image of blog author
Milani Notshe

Research Specialist

Last Updated

June 18, 2025

Table of Contents

Download PDF

Ready to get Started?

Let's Chat

Key Takeaways

Choosing the right payroll provider is crucial for any business, whether you're managing a small team or overseeing a global workforce. In fact, you can save up to 6 hours of the HR team’s time and decrease costs by 50% by outsourcing payroll. However, with so many payroll providers available, it can be difficult to determine which one best suits your needs. How can you ensure you're selecting a partner who offers reliability, transparency, and the right features? 

Navigating the complexities of payroll, tax compliance, and employee benefits can be overwhelming, but with the right provider, it becomes simple. To help you make an informed decision, we’ve put together a 9-factor payroll checklist that will help you refine your global payroll strategy and ensure you’re choosing a trusted payroll provider to support your business’s growth.

Key Factors To Consider When Selecting A Payroll Provider 

  1. Experience and Reputation
  2. Cost and Pricing
  3. Scalability and Flexibility
  4. Features and Services
  5. Ease of Use and Technology
  6. Security and Compliance
  7. Customer Support
  8. Analytics and Reporting
  9. Integration with Existing Tools

What are the Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Payroll Provider?

If you're having trouble choosing a global payroll solution, you're not alone - there are many providers out there to choose from. The variety of options available means that there’s a global payroll provider for nearly every type of business, whether you’re managing a few employees or expanding globally. The challenge, however, is finding the right fit for your specific needs. Below is a checklist of essential factors to consider when selecting a payroll provider: 

1. Experience and Reputation

When choosing a payroll provider, the provider’s track record is crucial. How long have they been in business? Do they have positive client testimonials? A payroll provider with a solid reputation will offer more reliability and expertise, particularly in handling payroll across multiple countries. For instance, if your business is expanding into Europe, a provider with experience in that region can offer valuable insight into local payroll laws.

2. Cost and Pricing

The cost of payroll services can vary widely. Many payroll providers offer transparent pricing, with base fees typically ranging from $20 to $100 per month, along with per-employee fees from $1 to $15. Make sure to ask for a detailed quote to avoid hidden fees. Transparent pricing helps businesses manage their budget effectively and avoid unexpected costs down the line.

3. Scalability and Flexibility

A good payroll provider should be able to grow with your business. Whether you’re adding seasonal employees or expanding internationally, your payroll provider must have the flexibility to accommodate new needs. For instance, a growing company might need a payroll provider that can easily scale to manage multiple locations or fluctuating employee numbers during peak seasons.

Scalable Payroll Solutions for Growing Businesses

Grow without limits with Payroll's flexible payroll manager. Easily handle payroll for new hires, automate payroll processes, create multi-vendor payroll reports, and more.

Speak to an expert

4. Features and Services

Different providers offer a variety of features, so you’ll want to consider what additional services they provide. These might include payroll processing, time tracking, tax filing, direct deposits, PTO tracking, and even benefits administration. Choosing a provider that offers  full-service payroll systems will simplify management for your HR team. For example, Playroll not only handles payroll for your global team and payroll management services to consolidate your operations, but also offers services like compliance management and benefits administration.

5. Ease of Use and Technology

The platform should be user-friendly and easy to navigate, even if you don’t have a payroll background. Consider whether the system includes mobile apps or dashboards that allow you to manage payroll on the go. Integration with other business systems, such as accounting software or HR management tools, is another essential factor to simplify your overall workflow.

6. Security and Compliance

Payroll involves dealing with sensitive employee information, so payroll security should be a top priority. Nearly half of small business owners have dealt with a cyberattack, and over 70% of these attacks target small businesses. That’s why it’s crucial to choose a provider that uses strong security measures, like encryption and multi-factor authentication, and have robust compliance credentials to back them up. You should also make sure they stay updated on tax laws and employment regulations in every country you do business in.

7. Customer Support

Having access to reliable, responsive customer support is a must. Payroll issues can pop up at any time, so you need to count on your provider for quick help. Providers that offer 24/7 support are especially helpful if your business works across multiple time zones. Also, consider looking for self-service options for employees to lighten the load on your HR team.

8. Analytics and Reporting

Advanced reporting capabilities can help you gain insights into your payroll data and make informed decisions about your workforce. Look for a provider that offers in-depth analytics for HR and employee management, particularly if your business has fluctuating workforce needs. This can help you track performance, manage labor costs, and plan for future growth.

Payroll Analytics Dashboard & Features
Access detailed payroll analytics per region

9. Integration with Existing Tools

Your payroll provider should easily sync with the tools you’re already using, like HR software, time tracking systems, accounting programs, and benefits management platforms. This way, data flows smoothly between systems, helping to reduce the risk of errors caused by manual data entry.

Global Payroll the Easy Way

Global Payroll Dashboard
Get an overview of your payroll operations on Playroll

When choosing the right global payroll provider, it’s important to think about experience, cost, scalability, features, compliance, and support. Playroll is a great choice because it simplifies multi-country payroll, offers payroll automation software, and helps you stay compliant across regions. You can easily manage payroll for employees in different countries using one system, cutting down on complexity and reducing the need for multiple vendors. Plus, it offers strong analytics and compliance support.

With decades of experience as part of the VAT IT group, Playroll provides flexible solutions that grow with your business. Our platform ensures accurate tax filings, benefits management, and smooth payroll processing. And with responsive customer support, you’ll always have the help you need. Book a chat to learn how we can simplify your global payroll needs.

Author profile picture

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Milani Notshe

Milani is a seasoned research and content specialist at Playroll, a leading Employer Of Record (EOR) provider. Backed by a strong background in Politics, Philosophy and Economics, she specializes in identifying emerging compliance and global HR trends to keep employers up to date on the global employment landscape.

How To Choose A Payroll Provider FAQs

What is the best payroll service for small businesses?

The best payroll service for small businesses is one that offers a balance of affordability, ease of use, and essential features. Look for providers that offer transparent pricing with clear base fees and per-employee costs. Services like Playroll provide simple, automated payroll solutions that ensure compliance, handle tax filings, and allow for easy employee management, all without overwhelming your small business’s budget or resources.

How much should payroll services cost?

Payroll services typically cost between $20 to $100 per month as a base fee, with additional costs of $1 to $15 per employee. However, pricing can vary depending on the level of service, the number of employees, and the complexity of your payroll needs. Always ensure that the pricing structure is transparent, and that any additional services, such as tax filing or benefits administration, are clearly outlined to avoid hidden fees.

What are the must-have payroll software components?

Essential payroll software components include payroll processing, tax filing, direct deposit, PTO tracking, compliance tools, and reporting features, all of which help ensure accurate, timely payments and adherence to tax regulations.

Back to Top

HR Insights
to your inbox

Curated insights, tools and guides to win at global hiring and remote work, straight to your inbox.

Thank you for subscribing!
Failed to subscribe! Please try again.

Playroll will handle your data pursuant to its Privacy Policy

Need Help?

Chat to our Support Team.

Reach Out

Like What You See?

Hire Globally with Playroll.

Let's Talk